Skip to Content Go to sign in Skip to Primary Navigation Skip to Secondary Navigation Skip to Page Navigation Skip to Header Navigation Skip to Footer Navigation Read more about accessability options and our navigation

Physics Classroom is making strides to make our site accessible to everyone. Our site contains 6 navigation areas. The Primary, Secondary, and Page Level navigations have a screen reader version of their nav structure that allows using the left and right keys to navigate sibling navigation items, and up or down keys to navigate parent or child navigation items. The others can be navigated using tabs. The Primary Navigation handles the first 2 levels of site pages. The Secondary (which is not always available) handles the 3rd and 4th level of structure. The Page level navigation allows you to navigate the current page's headings quickly. The Header Navigation contains the Light/Dark Mode toggle, Search, Notifications and account login. The Breadcrumb Navigation contains the breadcrumb of the current page. If the current page has a breadcrumb, you can get to it by skipping to the content and tabbing in reverse (shift plus tab). The Footer Navigation contains links such as Privacy, Contact, about and terms. Some resources contain an Audio Player that can be activated by holding down the T key for 3 seconds, and then using K to pause and resume. While not every area of Physics Classroom is usable purely from keyboard and screen reader, we are committed to continue work on making this possible. If you have questions or need additional help, please use this link to contact us.

Return to screen reader navigation
Home Concept Builders Static Electricity Getting the Hang of Charge Help Help 12

Getting the Hang of Charge - Questions 12 Help

The type of charge an object possesses can be determined by observing its interactions with other objects of known charge. To make such a determination, you need to combine the observations with three simple rules regarding charge interactions:

  • Objects that possess opposite types of charge will be observed to attract each other.
  • Objects that possess the same type of charge will be observed to repel each other.
  • A neutral object and a charged object will always attract each other.

There are two similar versions of this question. Here are the two versions:

Version 1:

Three balloons are hung from the ceiling by threads. Balloon A is positively-charged. Balloons A and B attract each other. Balloons B and C attract each other. Balloon C attracts neutral paper bits. Balloon C is ________.


 
Version 2:
Three balloons are hung from the ceiling by threads. Balloon A is negatively-charged. Balloons A and B attract each other. Balloons B and C attract each other. Balloon C attracts neutral paper bits. Balloon C is ________.
 

It's All About Reasoning
Like a lot of our Concept Builders (but maybe more so with this one), you have some thinking and logical reasoning to do. The physics rules are straight-forward:

  • opposites attract,
  • likes repel, and
  • charged and neutral attract.

But the application of these simple rules can get complicated. Get yourself organized and prepare to reason.


The Game Plan
This question is about Balloon C. The charge of Balloon A is stated. But Balloon C does not interact with Balloon A; it only interacts with Balloon B and with neutral paper bits. It would be best to draw some conclusions based on the Paper Bits interaction. That is discussed in the next section - What's With the Paper Bits? Then do some reasoning regarding what you know about Balloon B based on its interaction with Balloon A. Finally, use what limited information you learn about Balloon B to reason towards the possibilities for Balloon C.


What's With the Paper Bits?
Note that Balloon C and neutral paper bits attract. This interaction provides evidence that Balloon C is charged. A neutral balloon and neutral paper bits would not interact at all. By itself, this observation does not tell you what type of charge Balloon C has ... but only that it is charged and not neutral. You will need to use the other observation of Balloon C with Balloon B to reason towards what type of charge it has. But for now, you can rule out the neutral possibility.


Repulsion Provides Evidence for Clear Conclusions
There is only one reason for why two objects repel - they have the same type of charge. Neutral objects can never be involved in repulsion. But unfortunately none of the depictions represent repulsions. Balloons A and B attract and Balloons B and C attract. So prepare yourself for some uncertainty since only observations of repulsion are capable of narrowing down the field of possibilities. Those uncertainties are discussed in the next paragraph.

 



Careful about Attraction
There are two reasons for why two balloons attract. They could be oppositely charged or one could be charged and the other is neutral. The observed attraction of Balloons A and B by itself is not conclusive enough evidence that B is charged. So from the interaction of Balloons A and B you are left with two possibilities for the charge state of Balloon B - it's opposite of A or its neutral. When you go to reason towards the charge of Balloon C, you must consider both of these possibilities. You will observe that Balloons B and C attract. And so make some conclusions about Balloon C based on the two possible charge states of Balloon B. And don't forgot about the paper bits observations (discussed above).

Try this link to The Physics Classroom Tutorial for more help with understanding charge interactions:

Charge Interactions

Concept Builder Teacher Notes Directions